Today researchers released two reports that validate the social benefits of smoking bans. By snuffing out the habit in restaurants and other public places, the often-controversial laws typically reduce heart attacks by 17% during the first year of enactment, concluded one of the studies. The other pegged the decrease at 26%.
The second study asserted that 154,000 people could be spared coronaries if a nationwide smoking ban was implemented.
Clearly the findings should steamroll the opposition to bans, a resistance that has often included restaurants. Still uncertain is how the industry will respond to this character-defining moment.
Is it going to react as it usually does, bashing the research and resorting to the black-and-white view that any burden on business is bad, anything less than a pro-business stance completely intolerable? Or will it take a more enlightened and realistic path, recognizing that many of its own members no longer embrace the sensibility that any management intrusion or strain on profits is intolerable? They no longer view issues like smoking bans, nutrition disclosure, or kids-marketing guidelines as the end of capitalism.
They’d prefer a creative accommodation of social causes, particularly when the result is an undeniable good.
Yet, even with the report pages barely creased, some industry members were lapsing into the old argument that they couldn’t survive another business-dampening measure.
This might trigger a few heart attacks, but I think the industry should drop the no-way line and instead push for a national smoking ban. One prohibition, from Maine to the westernmost Aleutians.
Fighting bans on a county-by-county or state-by-state basis is like trying to hold back the tide, especially with today’s indictment of the no-at-any-cost stance. The battle was turned long ago. The industry has to recognize that patrons who want to smoke should get takeout and climb back into their horse and buggies.
Practicalities aside, the industry would reach out to a younger constituency that can't abide the old-guard stances. They have trouble with the industry’s defense of menu items that pack thousands of calories or hundreds of salt grams. They’re sympathetic to demands that restaurants push their suppliers for more sustainable practices, from field to fork, and understand that ecological considerations have to be addressed. They'd like the industry to be a kindler, gentler employer, even if that means a higher outlay for labor.
I addressed a culinary class last Thursday and mentioned Starbucks’ health-care policy. It offers coverage to all staffers, including part-timers. Many of the students nodded their heads in agreement and admiration, as if to say, “’Bout time someone did.”
But if you think we’re about to join hands and launch into a rousing rendition of “Kumbaya,” don’t worry about needing any Purell. Instead of joining hands, make yours into a fist, and then aim it at the casino industry.
Because of the money that business generates, it has succeeded in wresting an exception to several smoking bans that affect virtually other service business. The argument can be summed up as, “Yes we did!”
That nonsense has to stop. If consumers can’t smoke in your places, they shouldn’t be allowed to smoke in casinos, either. Same with bars, airports, parks, bowling alleys, bingo halls, baseball stadiums, even churches. And restaurants should say as much, loud and clear.
If they’re going to do the right thing, do it all the way.
Showing posts with label lobbying. Show all posts
Showing posts with label lobbying. Show all posts
Monday, September 21, 2009
Sunday, August 30, 2009
Ted Kennedy & the restaurant industry
The restaurant industry lost one of its steadfast adversaries last week, the legendary Sen. Ted Kennedy. Even his bitterest opponents wouldn’t disrespect such a man by relishing his passing. But some in the business may secretly harbor relief, remembering Kennedy’s ardent fight for minimum wage hikes, worker benefits like parental leave, and any number of measures that foisted new costs and responsibilities on the trade.
It’s a shame their ideology blinds them from learning two key lessons from a 46-year public servant who undoubtedly ranks among the most committed ever to serve in the U.S. Senate.
At the very least, they should appreciate the fervor that drives someone who’s acting out of conviction to his ideals. Often, though less so today, restaurateurs oppose a law, regulation or social movement solely on the basis that it’ll cost them money, time or aggravation. They seem flummoxed that an undue burden on business isn’t enough of an objection to halt the other side.
The fallback is to equate the burden to lost jobs, as if anyone would really believe their motivation is keeping entry-level employment at the highest possible level.
Financial hardship is certainly a valid reason to oppose a measure. But some restaurateurs fail to appreciate that their opponents may, like Kennedy, be pushing a measure because they burn with the certainty it delivers a higher good. Arguing that something will cut profits just seems callused when the other side is insisting with conviction that a change in the status quo will help families, children, education, the underprivileged, social well-being, upward mobility, the hungry, or just leveling the playing field. Shortchanging investors or business owners is hardly the kryptonite counterargument against such righteous zeal.
It’s especially important for the trade to appreciate that ardor as values are reshaped by the recession. In a great social paradox, being harder pressed for money has prompted many people to downgrade its importance and elevate intangibles like connection, quality of life or having purpose. The industry can see it in dynamics like youngsters accepting lower wages for a position that resonates more with their principles. Is working for a greener company worth collecting 50 cents less an hour? How many of you would doubt it?
Similarly, survey after survey has shown that consumers are willing to pay more at a business that assumes a responsibility to the environment. Even with less to spend, they want to spend it with principle. Economics are trumped by values.
So what’s the industry to do to protect its business interests in a reasonable fashion?
As the posthumous tributes have all noted, Kennedy was the master of compromise and coalition-building. For too long, the industry’s lobbying position could be summed up as, “No.” No way, no how, no further discussion. Pitched opposition was the default setting.
Wouldn’t it be better to be a little Kennedy-esque? To work with adversaries and allies alike to find alternatives that protect business without drowning out other concerns, or refusing to shoulder some of the burden needed to benefit society as a whole?
The trade did it with the menu-disclosure bills that were introduced last year—accepting the concept of calorie counts being posted on chain menus, but tempering the requirements to ease the wallop.
Some industry old-timers must’ve clutched their chests when they saw the business calling for menu labeling, once the trade’s Freddie Krueger of causes.
But it will hopefully serve as a working model, in part because attitudes are changing within the industry’s workforce. An associate who works with tomorrow’s management says his young charges can’t understand why the business is always lining up on the wrong side of issues—matters like health, or worker benefits like sick leave, or, most pointedly of all, the environment. They’re often dismayed, if not embarrassed, by the trade’s political stance.
You can readily see it in the greening effort. Staffs are impatient with their employers’ commitment to sustainability. More expensive? So what? Many would no doubt favor government mandates to force the movement along.
The industry should do itself a favor and harness that zeal. With a little of what Kennedy practiced, it could use their ardor to hammer out a solution, instead of fostering a split between old and new attitudes.
It’s a shame their ideology blinds them from learning two key lessons from a 46-year public servant who undoubtedly ranks among the most committed ever to serve in the U.S. Senate.
At the very least, they should appreciate the fervor that drives someone who’s acting out of conviction to his ideals. Often, though less so today, restaurateurs oppose a law, regulation or social movement solely on the basis that it’ll cost them money, time or aggravation. They seem flummoxed that an undue burden on business isn’t enough of an objection to halt the other side.
The fallback is to equate the burden to lost jobs, as if anyone would really believe their motivation is keeping entry-level employment at the highest possible level.
Financial hardship is certainly a valid reason to oppose a measure. But some restaurateurs fail to appreciate that their opponents may, like Kennedy, be pushing a measure because they burn with the certainty it delivers a higher good. Arguing that something will cut profits just seems callused when the other side is insisting with conviction that a change in the status quo will help families, children, education, the underprivileged, social well-being, upward mobility, the hungry, or just leveling the playing field. Shortchanging investors or business owners is hardly the kryptonite counterargument against such righteous zeal.
It’s especially important for the trade to appreciate that ardor as values are reshaped by the recession. In a great social paradox, being harder pressed for money has prompted many people to downgrade its importance and elevate intangibles like connection, quality of life or having purpose. The industry can see it in dynamics like youngsters accepting lower wages for a position that resonates more with their principles. Is working for a greener company worth collecting 50 cents less an hour? How many of you would doubt it?
Similarly, survey after survey has shown that consumers are willing to pay more at a business that assumes a responsibility to the environment. Even with less to spend, they want to spend it with principle. Economics are trumped by values.
So what’s the industry to do to protect its business interests in a reasonable fashion?
As the posthumous tributes have all noted, Kennedy was the master of compromise and coalition-building. For too long, the industry’s lobbying position could be summed up as, “No.” No way, no how, no further discussion. Pitched opposition was the default setting.
Wouldn’t it be better to be a little Kennedy-esque? To work with adversaries and allies alike to find alternatives that protect business without drowning out other concerns, or refusing to shoulder some of the burden needed to benefit society as a whole?
The trade did it with the menu-disclosure bills that were introduced last year—accepting the concept of calorie counts being posted on chain menus, but tempering the requirements to ease the wallop.
Some industry old-timers must’ve clutched their chests when they saw the business calling for menu labeling, once the trade’s Freddie Krueger of causes.
But it will hopefully serve as a working model, in part because attitudes are changing within the industry’s workforce. An associate who works with tomorrow’s management says his young charges can’t understand why the business is always lining up on the wrong side of issues—matters like health, or worker benefits like sick leave, or, most pointedly of all, the environment. They’re often dismayed, if not embarrassed, by the trade’s political stance.
You can readily see it in the greening effort. Staffs are impatient with their employers’ commitment to sustainability. More expensive? So what? Many would no doubt favor government mandates to force the movement along.
The industry should do itself a favor and harness that zeal. With a little of what Kennedy practiced, it could use their ardor to hammer out a solution, instead of fostering a split between old and new attitudes.
Wednesday, June 10, 2009
Restaurants welcome a new menu labeling plan
Capitol Hill lawmakers have cleared the way for national menu disclosure standards by combining the pet bills of opposing sides into a new proposal that appears acceptable to all parties, including the restaurant chains that would have to abide by the law.
The compromise measure, jointly announced by the major stakeholders this afternoon, would mesh a labeling bill steadfastly opposed by the industry, Sen. Tom Harkin's Menu Education and Labeling Act (a.k.a. MEAL), with an alternative that was put forth last year by the restaurant business and its allies on the Hill, the Labeling Education and Nutrition Act (LEAN in sound bites). The breakthrough was acceptance by all parties of limiting the info disclosed on menus and menu boards to calorie counts. The other information that Harkin and his allies want chains to provide, like salt and fat content, would be provided in written forms available at the point of purchase.
The requirement would be binding on outlets of chains with at least 20 branches.
Sen. Tom Carper said the new measure, which has yet to be given a clever acronym as a name, has bipartisan support. Carper was a key sponsor of the LEAN Act, which the National Restaurant Association and other industry groups helped to craft.
The compromise bill is expected to be a component of any healthcare reform legislation that arises in the Senate in the next few weeks. The passage of such an omnibus measure would be an historic event, which suggests it will likely be hotly debated and undergo considerable consideration before anything is actually put on the books.
But the emergence of a bill less stringent than MEAL was hailed by the restaurant industry as a breakthrough. "We are pleased that industry, government and the public health community were able to come together and partner to reach a workable solution to this important issue," Clarence Otis, CEO of Red Lobster and Olive Garden parent Darden Restaurants Inc., said in a statement.
“We thank the Senators for their bipartisan leadership and for recognizing the importance of legislation that meets the needs of both the restaurant industry and our customers," Dawn Sweeney, CEO of the National Restaurant Association, said in her statement. "We look forward to working with Congress to enact this legislation."
Initial reports failed to reveal when the new labeling bill would take effect if passed, or what protections it would extend to chains that worry about legal challenges of the calorie counts they might post. Because food items can vary in size or even sugar content, a precise analysis might be impossible to deliver, they contend. They fear that consumers will allege in court that they were misled by the information provided.
The compromise measure, jointly announced by the major stakeholders this afternoon, would mesh a labeling bill steadfastly opposed by the industry, Sen. Tom Harkin's Menu Education and Labeling Act (a.k.a. MEAL), with an alternative that was put forth last year by the restaurant business and its allies on the Hill, the Labeling Education and Nutrition Act (LEAN in sound bites). The breakthrough was acceptance by all parties of limiting the info disclosed on menus and menu boards to calorie counts. The other information that Harkin and his allies want chains to provide, like salt and fat content, would be provided in written forms available at the point of purchase.
The requirement would be binding on outlets of chains with at least 20 branches.
Sen. Tom Carper said the new measure, which has yet to be given a clever acronym as a name, has bipartisan support. Carper was a key sponsor of the LEAN Act, which the National Restaurant Association and other industry groups helped to craft.
The compromise bill is expected to be a component of any healthcare reform legislation that arises in the Senate in the next few weeks. The passage of such an omnibus measure would be an historic event, which suggests it will likely be hotly debated and undergo considerable consideration before anything is actually put on the books.
But the emergence of a bill less stringent than MEAL was hailed by the restaurant industry as a breakthrough. "We are pleased that industry, government and the public health community were able to come together and partner to reach a workable solution to this important issue," Clarence Otis, CEO of Red Lobster and Olive Garden parent Darden Restaurants Inc., said in a statement.
“We thank the Senators for their bipartisan leadership and for recognizing the importance of legislation that meets the needs of both the restaurant industry and our customers," Dawn Sweeney, CEO of the National Restaurant Association, said in her statement. "We look forward to working with Congress to enact this legislation."
Initial reports failed to reveal when the new labeling bill would take effect if passed, or what protections it would extend to chains that worry about legal challenges of the calorie counts they might post. Because food items can vary in size or even sugar content, a precise analysis might be impossible to deliver, they contend. They fear that consumers will allege in court that they were misled by the information provided.
Tuesday, March 31, 2009
The industry has to rethink paid sick leave
My friends accuse me of being a shill for the restaurant industry because I won’t condemn the chains, a requisite for anyone who wants to wear black and discuss the latest Vanity Fair. But that doesn’t mean I support everything thing the trade oes, particularly when it comes to legislation. Consider, for instance, the prickly matter of paid sick leave.
A proposal reportedly gaining favor in Connecticut would require restaurants and other businesses that employ more than 50 people to provide 6.5 paid sick days per year. If the measure proceeds, the state would become the first in the nation to mandate the benefit, though Massachusetts and Illinois may not be far behind. San Francisco and Washington, D.C., already have a requirement on their books. Milwaukee residents approved a ballot initiative last year that called for paid sick leave, but the early February start date has been postponed because of a legal challenge from employers.
The restaurant industry insists it can’t afford to double up on pay for a position whose holder has taken sick—what the ill individual would get, plus what a replacement would collect. I don’t disagree.
But consider the alternative to paid sick leave. A restaurant employee is vomiting and suffering from diarrhea. He or she has a choice of either coming in and getting paid, or staying home and foregoing the money. There’s not much to weigh there, at least not from their standpoint. And that’s even if they work in the kitchen.
An employee in that condition is supposed to stay home, but there’s certainly an incentive to flout the rules. If the problem is viral, the employee is almost certainly still infectious. Indeed, research indicates that someone can still pass along a norovirus, the cause of what most people would characterize as the flu, considerably longer than they’re symptomatic.
Gloves, hand washing, the use of utensils and other precautions can avert risk. But they’re less than fool-proof in a harried restaurant kitchen, where a staff in the weeds might forget or skip what they’d recognize in cooler moments as a must-do.
In that environment, a sick employee poses a danger, to guests, co-workers and the business, if there’s a publicized outbreak of an illness. Moving the person out of the kitchen would be one potential remedy, if another staffer could be displaced or directed to trade places. Now you have a possibly infectious person in the dining room or bar.
A better solution is paid sick leave. The unsolved problem is how to make it affordable.
Somehow, the industry has to find a way of doing it. The obvious one is some sort of pool, where everyone pays in a little so contributors can draw out the shared funds when they’re the ones who need it.
But few operators want to hear that. They’d rather bet they can hold the line and fend off an expense that really could put them under, as a straight employer mandate might.
The situation in Connecticut and elsewhere will hopefully prompt them to reconsider, before their options are narrowed to paying a fortune or facing costly sanctions.
A proposal reportedly gaining favor in Connecticut would require restaurants and other businesses that employ more than 50 people to provide 6.5 paid sick days per year. If the measure proceeds, the state would become the first in the nation to mandate the benefit, though Massachusetts and Illinois may not be far behind. San Francisco and Washington, D.C., already have a requirement on their books. Milwaukee residents approved a ballot initiative last year that called for paid sick leave, but the early February start date has been postponed because of a legal challenge from employers.
The restaurant industry insists it can’t afford to double up on pay for a position whose holder has taken sick—what the ill individual would get, plus what a replacement would collect. I don’t disagree.
But consider the alternative to paid sick leave. A restaurant employee is vomiting and suffering from diarrhea. He or she has a choice of either coming in and getting paid, or staying home and foregoing the money. There’s not much to weigh there, at least not from their standpoint. And that’s even if they work in the kitchen.
An employee in that condition is supposed to stay home, but there’s certainly an incentive to flout the rules. If the problem is viral, the employee is almost certainly still infectious. Indeed, research indicates that someone can still pass along a norovirus, the cause of what most people would characterize as the flu, considerably longer than they’re symptomatic.
Gloves, hand washing, the use of utensils and other precautions can avert risk. But they’re less than fool-proof in a harried restaurant kitchen, where a staff in the weeds might forget or skip what they’d recognize in cooler moments as a must-do.
In that environment, a sick employee poses a danger, to guests, co-workers and the business, if there’s a publicized outbreak of an illness. Moving the person out of the kitchen would be one potential remedy, if another staffer could be displaced or directed to trade places. Now you have a possibly infectious person in the dining room or bar.
A better solution is paid sick leave. The unsolved problem is how to make it affordable.
Somehow, the industry has to find a way of doing it. The obvious one is some sort of pool, where everyone pays in a little so contributors can draw out the shared funds when they’re the ones who need it.
But few operators want to hear that. They’d rather bet they can hold the line and fend off an expense that really could put them under, as a straight employer mandate might.
The situation in Connecticut and elsewhere will hopefully prompt them to reconsider, before their options are narrowed to paying a fortune or facing costly sanctions.
Labels:
Connecticut,
legislation,
lobbying,
paid sick leave
Friday, March 27, 2009
Caterers protest the protests against biz events
Consider this scenario: Mega Screw & Trust, a New York bank, is teetering on the brink of insolvency until feds showed up with bags of greenbacks from the Troubled Assets Relief Program. It stays open, and even decides to proceed with the big party it was planning for 20-year veterans who met their cost-cutting goals. But the press finds out and makes a stink, prompting MST to cancel the five-figure fete.
Sunshine Bank & Kitten Saver, a medium-sized competitor that stayed financially fit, witnesses the fallout and decides it’d better pull the plug on a celebration honoring the employees who came up with the best give-back programs for local charities. It alerts Joe’s Neighborhood Grill that it won’t be taking the back room next Friday. The banquet’s off.
Edmund Schmoe III, a former Mega Screw & Trust VP who now works as a banquet waiter at Joe’s, finds out he won’t be needed next Friday. His first response is letting his brothers know they can’t count on a contribution from him for the catered party they were planning for their father’s birthday. The siblings decide to cancel.
That sequence of events, or at least a segment of it, has transpired often enough to prompt a muted outcry from the National Association of Catering Executives. Treading carefully, the group yesterday released survey results that indicate 90% of the nation’s caterers and meeting planners have lost business because of the outcry over businesses holding events in the current economic climate. Almost the same percentage of respondents say the public outrage has made that climate worse.
"While I understand that in these times it is important to spend carefully, the bashing of the catering, events, meetings and travel business is not only unfair and prejudicial to our industry, it is counterproductive to economic recovery," said Greg Casella, the San Jose, Calif., caterer who serves as president of NACE.
If the situation is that bad for caterers, imagine the fallout for restaurants. Not only are they losing party and banquet business, but even routine expense account meals.
The question is, what can be done about it? As Restaurant Reality Check previously reported, the National Restaurant Association quietly pushed back last month against federal legislation that would have mandated cuts in banquets, catering and other foodservice expenses by companies receiving bailout funds. How can any group publicly call for those types of expenses to continue when so many people are struggling to afford groceries, never mind a party?
Still, NACE deserves a lot of credit for spotlighting a facet of the situation that deserves consideration. As it noted in releasing yesterday’s statement, its membership extends to 4,000 businesses, which obviously must employ a big multiple of that number. Those people are struggling to eat, too.
Sunshine Bank & Kitten Saver, a medium-sized competitor that stayed financially fit, witnesses the fallout and decides it’d better pull the plug on a celebration honoring the employees who came up with the best give-back programs for local charities. It alerts Joe’s Neighborhood Grill that it won’t be taking the back room next Friday. The banquet’s off.
Edmund Schmoe III, a former Mega Screw & Trust VP who now works as a banquet waiter at Joe’s, finds out he won’t be needed next Friday. His first response is letting his brothers know they can’t count on a contribution from him for the catered party they were planning for their father’s birthday. The siblings decide to cancel.
That sequence of events, or at least a segment of it, has transpired often enough to prompt a muted outcry from the National Association of Catering Executives. Treading carefully, the group yesterday released survey results that indicate 90% of the nation’s caterers and meeting planners have lost business because of the outcry over businesses holding events in the current economic climate. Almost the same percentage of respondents say the public outrage has made that climate worse.
"While I understand that in these times it is important to spend carefully, the bashing of the catering, events, meetings and travel business is not only unfair and prejudicial to our industry, it is counterproductive to economic recovery," said Greg Casella, the San Jose, Calif., caterer who serves as president of NACE.
If the situation is that bad for caterers, imagine the fallout for restaurants. Not only are they losing party and banquet business, but even routine expense account meals.
The question is, what can be done about it? As Restaurant Reality Check previously reported, the National Restaurant Association quietly pushed back last month against federal legislation that would have mandated cuts in banquets, catering and other foodservice expenses by companies receiving bailout funds. How can any group publicly call for those types of expenses to continue when so many people are struggling to afford groceries, never mind a party?
Still, NACE deserves a lot of credit for spotlighting a facet of the situation that deserves consideration. As it noted in releasing yesterday’s statement, its membership extends to 4,000 businesses, which obviously must employ a big multiple of that number. Those people are struggling to eat, too.
Sunday, March 1, 2009
Industry lobbyists look to walk a fine line
The restaurant industry will have to be careful as it contends with a legislative threat that arose last week on Capitol Hill. A provision introduced in the Senate would prohibit the 421 financial institutions receiving federal bailout assistance from holding parties, celebratory dinners or other entertainment-type events, according to Michael Kaufman, the current chairman of the National Restaurant Association.
“Think of the effects of that bill on the hospitality industry,” Kaufman said during a presentation at the New York restaurant show this afternoon in New York City.
Kaufman cited the initiative as an example of the legislative proposals the Association regularly monitors and attempts to temper or defeat.
Good luck this time around. Lynch mobs probably formed after word leaked out of lavish parties being held by some of the banks that received billions in aid from the U.S. Treasury Department. The NRA will have to move delicately as it tries to preserve a lucrative source of event business for restaurants. Otherwise, it’ll look as if the industry is an enabler for the banks’ lavish shenanigans.
During his presentation, Kaufman also revealed the NRA is in the later stages of developing a new healthcare insurance program for the industry. He noted that the Association’s current chief, Dawn Sweeney, joined the group about a year ago after helping AARP develop a breakthrough healthcare program for its members. That acumen, he suggested, is being applied to the industry’s longstanding quest for affordable insurance for the rank-and-file.
An NRA director in attendance said he believes the program under development could cut the healthcare bill for him and his wife by more than $3,000.
“Think of the effects of that bill on the hospitality industry,” Kaufman said during a presentation at the New York restaurant show this afternoon in New York City.
Kaufman cited the initiative as an example of the legislative proposals the Association regularly monitors and attempts to temper or defeat.
Good luck this time around. Lynch mobs probably formed after word leaked out of lavish parties being held by some of the banks that received billions in aid from the U.S. Treasury Department. The NRA will have to move delicately as it tries to preserve a lucrative source of event business for restaurants. Otherwise, it’ll look as if the industry is an enabler for the banks’ lavish shenanigans.
During his presentation, Kaufman also revealed the NRA is in the later stages of developing a new healthcare insurance program for the industry. He noted that the Association’s current chief, Dawn Sweeney, joined the group about a year ago after helping AARP develop a breakthrough healthcare program for its members. That acumen, he suggested, is being applied to the industry’s longstanding quest for affordable insurance for the rank-and-file.
An NRA director in attendance said he believes the program under development could cut the healthcare bill for him and his wife by more than $3,000.
Sunday, February 15, 2009
Tip laws draw new scrutiny
Raise a glass in sympathy to the industry’s public affairs officers. It’s bad enough they’ll be rooting for days through Congress’ stimulus package, looking for possible boons to their companies or the business overall. Now there’s the Whack-a-Mole marathon that statehouses commenced last week, with new tip bills popping up faster than peanut product recalls. And if their chain has any restaurants in the U.K., they might as well start pounding the Red Bull right away. Cut with a little vodka, perhaps.
Most of the proposals deal with the tip credit, a provision of wage-and-hour laws that assumes servers earn most of their income in gratuities. In states where a credit is on the books, employers have to pay only a portion of the mandated minimum wage, with the rest coming from what customers leave on the table as tips. Many of the jurisdictions follow federal law, which requires employers to pay tipped staffers only $2.13 an hour, compared with the full minimum of $6.55.
The waiter, waitress or bartender makes no less than he or she would if they collected the full minimum wage—and, indeed, they often make considerably more. Rather, the credit merely allows some of that pay to come directly from patrons.
But movements afoot in states like Maine, Kansas and Missouri aim to change that situation, which has been the norm in all but eight states since the 1980s. Labor proponents say it’s unfair for servers to collect only a small fraction of what their non-tipped colleagues are paid under state wage requirements. Whatever they get in tips, the advocates argue, is icing on the cake, a gift they should be entitled to keep in addition to their hourly pay.
Restaurants, of course, argue that they can’t afford to pay more in wages right now. Some also point out that the traditional tip is 15%, whereas the profit margin for most restaurants is in the single digits, and often under 5%.
Indeed, the trade cited its dire economic conditions in trying, unsuccessfully, to institute a tip credit in Montana. The proposal was just defeated in the state Senate by a 29-21 bipartisan vote.
The industry was more successful earlier this month in Wyoming, beating back a proposal to adjust the tip credit there. The measure would have raised the hourly minimum wage for servers by $3 an hour.
Yet to be decided is a proposal in Maine, where a new union-like group patterned after one in New York City, the innocuous-sounding Restaurant Opportunities Center, is pushing to raise the minimum wage of servers to 60% of the mandated rate for other workers. The current floor for servers is 50% of the full hourly wage.
A measure under consideration in Kansas would raise servers’ minimum to $4.35, from the current $2.13.
In Hawaii, restaurateurs are leading the charge to change the state’s tip credit, which allows them to lower servers’ minimum pay by just a quarter an hour, to $7. They’re arguing that the island state’s laws shouldn’t be out of sync with the pay scale of the mainland, and cite the long and growing list of restaurants that have been shuttered there by the economic freefall.
If you ask me, both sides have compelling arguments, given the state of the economy. There just aren’t enough dollars going into restaurants, so employers and employees are trying to adjust the split in whatever way is most favorable to them. It’s understandable, just not easily resolved.
So let’s hope those public affairs officers find plenty of hopeful indications within the stimulus package. In the meantime, send ‘em a whole bottle of the good stuff. Charge it to the bankruptcy lawyers, whose industry seems to be the only one doing better in this environment.
Most of the proposals deal with the tip credit, a provision of wage-and-hour laws that assumes servers earn most of their income in gratuities. In states where a credit is on the books, employers have to pay only a portion of the mandated minimum wage, with the rest coming from what customers leave on the table as tips. Many of the jurisdictions follow federal law, which requires employers to pay tipped staffers only $2.13 an hour, compared with the full minimum of $6.55.
The waiter, waitress or bartender makes no less than he or she would if they collected the full minimum wage—and, indeed, they often make considerably more. Rather, the credit merely allows some of that pay to come directly from patrons.
But movements afoot in states like Maine, Kansas and Missouri aim to change that situation, which has been the norm in all but eight states since the 1980s. Labor proponents say it’s unfair for servers to collect only a small fraction of what their non-tipped colleagues are paid under state wage requirements. Whatever they get in tips, the advocates argue, is icing on the cake, a gift they should be entitled to keep in addition to their hourly pay.
Restaurants, of course, argue that they can’t afford to pay more in wages right now. Some also point out that the traditional tip is 15%, whereas the profit margin for most restaurants is in the single digits, and often under 5%.
Indeed, the trade cited its dire economic conditions in trying, unsuccessfully, to institute a tip credit in Montana. The proposal was just defeated in the state Senate by a 29-21 bipartisan vote.
The industry was more successful earlier this month in Wyoming, beating back a proposal to adjust the tip credit there. The measure would have raised the hourly minimum wage for servers by $3 an hour.
Yet to be decided is a proposal in Maine, where a new union-like group patterned after one in New York City, the innocuous-sounding Restaurant Opportunities Center, is pushing to raise the minimum wage of servers to 60% of the mandated rate for other workers. The current floor for servers is 50% of the full hourly wage.
A measure under consideration in Kansas would raise servers’ minimum to $4.35, from the current $2.13.
In Hawaii, restaurateurs are leading the charge to change the state’s tip credit, which allows them to lower servers’ minimum pay by just a quarter an hour, to $7. They’re arguing that the island state’s laws shouldn’t be out of sync with the pay scale of the mainland, and cite the long and growing list of restaurants that have been shuttered there by the economic freefall.
If you ask me, both sides have compelling arguments, given the state of the economy. There just aren’t enough dollars going into restaurants, so employers and employees are trying to adjust the split in whatever way is most favorable to them. It’s understandable, just not easily resolved.
So let’s hope those public affairs officers find plenty of hopeful indications within the stimulus package. In the meantime, send ‘em a whole bottle of the good stuff. Charge it to the bankruptcy lawyers, whose industry seems to be the only one doing better in this environment.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)