The restaurant industry lost one of its revolutionaries last week, though it’s strange to apply that label to an arch capitalist like Abe Gustin.
He’ll be remembered as the person who founded Applebee’s, even though the concept was actually the brainchild of Bill Palmer, now of Up The Creek Without a Paddle. What Gustin truly founded was a simpler, far more effective approach to franchising, with the principle of partnership elevated to an art form.
Plenty of franchisors pledged to make their relationship with franchisees a symbiotic one, but Gustin had learned how empty those words could be. As he would candidly recount in interviews, being a franchisee of Taco Bell in the mid-1980s had taught him how subordinate the licensee could be. He felt the home office was dictating the terms and controlling franchisees’ growth, instead of working in tandem.
Gustin said he tried to set up Applebee’s franchisee programs to be just the opposite. For one thing, he limited the number of franchisees to a few dozen, so the field-level operators wouldn’t be competing with one another for turf, sales or employees.
And they were given a firm say in what they served, and not only through the advisory council that virtually all chains set up to give franchisees a voice in shaping menus. Long before local specialties were given the spotlight they get today, Applebee’s franchisees were invited to fill out their menus with regional specialties. The home office set about 80% of the listing, and the field operators chose the rest.
More important, franchisees attested that the home office heard what they said—maybe not all the time, but enough to make them feel they had a strong influence on the brand’s direction.
When franchisees felt their territories were running out of room for more Applebee’s restaurants, the home office went out and bought a second franchise concept, Rio Bravo. Since it, too, was developed in part by Palmer, headquarters figured it was the right means for franchisees to keep opening outlets.
It was wrong, as franchisees and investors soon let management know. Rio Bravo didn’t work for the system, so the brand was divested. Everyone went back to expanding the Applebee’s chain again, using smaller prototypes and smarter siting strategies.
The proof of Gustin’s approach to franchising was Applebee’s phenomenal growth. Before he controlled the brand, it was owned by W.R. Grace, which treated it like a glorified lemonade stand. It grew to 42 stores, if memory serves me correctly, which made it a miniscule part of the chemical giant’s portfolio. Its other restaurant holdings, just to put it in perspective, were Del Taco and Houlihan’s.
When Grace decided to exit the restaurant business and sell those brands, no one seemed to even notice Applebee’s. Houlihan’s was the plum. With barely any notice taken, Gustin was able to secure what would become casual dining’s longest string of restaurants.
It would grow to far more than 1,000 restaurants, a size more befitting a fast-food chain than a group of full-service places. But Gustin and his lieutenants—some might say disciples—made it happen.
The fuel was franchisees’ capital. Gustin kept the fire stoked.
The industry shall miss him for sure.
Thursday, October 14, 2010
Saturday, October 9, 2010
Ruby Tuesday's new seafood concept
As if Ruby Tuesday didn’t have enough choices on its menu of development options, the casual-dining giant is prepping one more type of restaurant it can use to replace weak namesake stores. The company alerted investors earlier this week that it will open a “seafood health concept” later this year.
Management didn’t divulge the name or many particulars about the venture, saying only that it would be one more option for salvaging underperforming Ruby Tuesday sites. Executives lumped it together with the two replacement concepts that were identified earlier, Jim ‘n Nicks and Truffles.
Like those, they explained, the seafood restaurant could replace a played-out Ruby Tuesday at a cost of under $500,000, and generate annual revenues of more than $1 million.
CEO Sandy Beall explained that 23% of a Ruby Tuesday’s guests, or roughly one in four, already order seafood. “It’ll just be a more seafood-oriented Ruby Tuesday, really,” he said during the conference call with analysts. “And it’s very relevant based on what people are eating and their health and so forth.”
The big benefit, he said, would be differentiation from all the other so-called grill-and-bar concepts, like Chili’s, T.G.I. Friday’s and Applebee’s
An analyst voiced his concern that Ruby Tuesday would be entering a sector where even long-established brands are facing considerable challenges. “We can all think of the biggest fish in the sea who is struggling with difficult trends,” said Robert Derrington, the restaurant analyst for Morgan, Keegan. He didn’t name that brand, Red Lobster, by name.
He noted, however, that Ruby Tuesday had experience with seafood restaurants.
Yes, said Beall. The company ran the L&N Seafood Grill chain when both casual-dining brands were part of Morrison, a large contract-feeding company.
Investors also heard the Ruby’s plan to use several young concepts as its expansion vehicles. It recently secured rights to develop units of Lime Fresh Mexican Grill, a fast-casual chain that currently has six stores open.
“As far as the economics go, it's really very, very similar to Chipotle,” said chief marketing officer Mark Young.
Wok Hay, a fast-casual brand that Ruby’s acquired several years ago and subsequently upgraded into a full-service operation, wasn’t mentioned. Ruby had cited it several months ago as a possible replacement concept for tired Ruby Tuesday outlets. It also cited it at that time as a restaurant that could be built on new sites.
Meanwhile, management noted that the first Jim ‘n Nicks is open and generating sales that should top $1.5 million on an annual basis.
They said Ruby’s first Truffles, an upscale casual format, would open next month.
Management didn’t divulge the name or many particulars about the venture, saying only that it would be one more option for salvaging underperforming Ruby Tuesday sites. Executives lumped it together with the two replacement concepts that were identified earlier, Jim ‘n Nicks and Truffles.
Like those, they explained, the seafood restaurant could replace a played-out Ruby Tuesday at a cost of under $500,000, and generate annual revenues of more than $1 million.
CEO Sandy Beall explained that 23% of a Ruby Tuesday’s guests, or roughly one in four, already order seafood. “It’ll just be a more seafood-oriented Ruby Tuesday, really,” he said during the conference call with analysts. “And it’s very relevant based on what people are eating and their health and so forth.”
The big benefit, he said, would be differentiation from all the other so-called grill-and-bar concepts, like Chili’s, T.G.I. Friday’s and Applebee’s
An analyst voiced his concern that Ruby Tuesday would be entering a sector where even long-established brands are facing considerable challenges. “We can all think of the biggest fish in the sea who is struggling with difficult trends,” said Robert Derrington, the restaurant analyst for Morgan, Keegan. He didn’t name that brand, Red Lobster, by name.
He noted, however, that Ruby Tuesday had experience with seafood restaurants.
Yes, said Beall. The company ran the L&N Seafood Grill chain when both casual-dining brands were part of Morrison, a large contract-feeding company.
Investors also heard the Ruby’s plan to use several young concepts as its expansion vehicles. It recently secured rights to develop units of Lime Fresh Mexican Grill, a fast-casual chain that currently has six stores open.
“As far as the economics go, it's really very, very similar to Chipotle,” said chief marketing officer Mark Young.
Wok Hay, a fast-casual brand that Ruby’s acquired several years ago and subsequently upgraded into a full-service operation, wasn’t mentioned. Ruby had cited it several months ago as a possible replacement concept for tired Ruby Tuesday outlets. It also cited it at that time as a restaurant that could be built on new sites.
Meanwhile, management noted that the first Jim ‘n Nicks is open and generating sales that should top $1.5 million on an annual basis.
They said Ruby’s first Truffles, an upscale casual format, would open next month.
Friday, October 8, 2010
The food industry's future, in high def
In the course of covering the restaurant business, I routinely hear savants proclaim what sorts of places and foods will catch the industry’s fancy in the months and years ahead. The future they’re sketching bears little resemblance to the one young kitchen talents are already setting out to build.
I say that after listening for three days to the business plans of 21 would-be graduates from the Institute of Culinary Education in New York City. As a final exam of sorts, the students develop an idea for a business and pitch it to the class. Invited to attend are three industry veterans who act as if they’re prospective investors, asking questions, providing feedback and generally helping the students sharpen their presentations. I was one of the industry elders tapped to play constructive critic.
The students had spent the six-month semester developing their business concepts, and it showed. The lot were brilliant—creative, finely detailed to demonstrate their viability, and decidedly real world, reflecting what the students had learned in the field as well as the classroom.
I won’t divulge any of the ideas because this is an industry of thieves. Then again, most of the restaurateurs I know would have trouble copycatting concepts that pivot on marshmallow, faro, free shots, egg creams, cowgirls, German sailors, and broke hipsters. (If you want an explanation of those elements, contact me and I’ll either pass you along to the student or shed as much light as I can without giving away the idea.)
Indeed, if restaurateurs were looking for ideas to pinch, they’d have found few suitable for their world. The presentations left little doubt that tomorrow’s chefs are choosing food shops, not restaurants, as the galleries for their arts.
More than a third of the pitches I heard dealt with retailing in some way. Several of the concepts were out-and-out storefronts, selling everything from flasks and coffee to Romanian vintages for wine virgins.
Other students aired their intention to sell a retail product via food or specialty shops. One already had an operation lined up to carry her product. Another brought in a gift basket of her wares.
The class’ instructor, the former restaurateur Alan Someck, explained to me that the students had witnessed the rigors of running a restaurant or a high-volume kitchen during their internships and work in the industry. That lifestyle might not hold the appeal it once did for youngsters aspiring to earn lots of green in whites. They were clearly more open to alternative paths, like the food and restaurant-focused web site that one student planned to open.
But the students also seemed to lack the black-and-white attitude of yesterday’s restaurant industry, which saw itself as a world apart from food retailing. The ones who planned to open a restaurant after graduation almost to a person included a retail component in their brainchild. Those stations would sell everything from meat to customized gifts.
Along the same lines, a goodly number of the plans broke out sales projections for catering, even when their signature product wasn’t something you’d associate with that sort of service—drink flights, for example.
And quite a few presenters said they intended to use trucks, carts and stands to offer their products where would-be customers are likely to be, a further departure from the dining-room mindset of past generations.
I have absolutely no doubt that many of the students whose plans I evaluated will be extremely successful in their ventures. They’re going to be tomorrow’s stars, albeit in a much different industry than the one we see today.
I say that after listening for three days to the business plans of 21 would-be graduates from the Institute of Culinary Education in New York City. As a final exam of sorts, the students develop an idea for a business and pitch it to the class. Invited to attend are three industry veterans who act as if they’re prospective investors, asking questions, providing feedback and generally helping the students sharpen their presentations. I was one of the industry elders tapped to play constructive critic.
The students had spent the six-month semester developing their business concepts, and it showed. The lot were brilliant—creative, finely detailed to demonstrate their viability, and decidedly real world, reflecting what the students had learned in the field as well as the classroom.
I won’t divulge any of the ideas because this is an industry of thieves. Then again, most of the restaurateurs I know would have trouble copycatting concepts that pivot on marshmallow, faro, free shots, egg creams, cowgirls, German sailors, and broke hipsters. (If you want an explanation of those elements, contact me and I’ll either pass you along to the student or shed as much light as I can without giving away the idea.)
Indeed, if restaurateurs were looking for ideas to pinch, they’d have found few suitable for their world. The presentations left little doubt that tomorrow’s chefs are choosing food shops, not restaurants, as the galleries for their arts.
More than a third of the pitches I heard dealt with retailing in some way. Several of the concepts were out-and-out storefronts, selling everything from flasks and coffee to Romanian vintages for wine virgins.
Other students aired their intention to sell a retail product via food or specialty shops. One already had an operation lined up to carry her product. Another brought in a gift basket of her wares.
The class’ instructor, the former restaurateur Alan Someck, explained to me that the students had witnessed the rigors of running a restaurant or a high-volume kitchen during their internships and work in the industry. That lifestyle might not hold the appeal it once did for youngsters aspiring to earn lots of green in whites. They were clearly more open to alternative paths, like the food and restaurant-focused web site that one student planned to open.
But the students also seemed to lack the black-and-white attitude of yesterday’s restaurant industry, which saw itself as a world apart from food retailing. The ones who planned to open a restaurant after graduation almost to a person included a retail component in their brainchild. Those stations would sell everything from meat to customized gifts.
Along the same lines, a goodly number of the plans broke out sales projections for catering, even when their signature product wasn’t something you’d associate with that sort of service—drink flights, for example.
And quite a few presenters said they intended to use trucks, carts and stands to offer their products where would-be customers are likely to be, a further departure from the dining-room mindset of past generations.
I have absolutely no doubt that many of the students whose plans I evaluated will be extremely successful in their ventures. They’re going to be tomorrow’s stars, albeit in a much different industry than the one we see today.
Sunday, October 3, 2010
What Wendy's has learned about salads
Wendy’s held a virtual press conference last week to underscore the health benefits of its new mix-and-match menu program, Pick 2. As far as I know it was the first time a restaurant giant has held a communications event expressly for bloggers.
The resurging burger chain clearly hoped we’d pass along information about the new $4.99 deal to prospective customers. But in explaining the offer, executives divulged information that should be of interest to any restaurateur who wants to appease salad-hunting patrons.
When Wendy’s decided to revamp its salads, it discussed the prospects with consumers, explained communications director Kitty Munger. They told the chain that there are a few things that bug them about a bowl of greens.
For instance, they don’t like the lettuce in their salads to be wet. As a result, said Munger, Wendy’s has outfitted every unit with a salad spinner.
Patrons also stressed they don’t like gnawing on big hunks of lettuce or ingredients. They want the components of a salad to be cut into smaller, bite-sized pieces. Wendy’s is obliging them, Munger said, by providing everything in its new salad line in fork-able pieces.
The feedback revealed that Wendy’s targeted customers want additional textures in their salad, particularly croutons and pieces of tortilla. Wendy’s has obliged them.
Finally, Munger recounted, Wendy’s learned that consumers want what she termed “flavor excitement.” She explained that Wendy’s tried to be a little adventurous with the new salad line by using ingredients like cayenne pepper and pecans kicked up with sea salt.
As I’ve noted in an earlier post, I’ve tried the new salads. They’re a true advance for fast food. Little did I know how much research had gone into the line.
The resurging burger chain clearly hoped we’d pass along information about the new $4.99 deal to prospective customers. But in explaining the offer, executives divulged information that should be of interest to any restaurateur who wants to appease salad-hunting patrons.
When Wendy’s decided to revamp its salads, it discussed the prospects with consumers, explained communications director Kitty Munger. They told the chain that there are a few things that bug them about a bowl of greens.
For instance, they don’t like the lettuce in their salads to be wet. As a result, said Munger, Wendy’s has outfitted every unit with a salad spinner.
Patrons also stressed they don’t like gnawing on big hunks of lettuce or ingredients. They want the components of a salad to be cut into smaller, bite-sized pieces. Wendy’s is obliging them, Munger said, by providing everything in its new salad line in fork-able pieces.
The feedback revealed that Wendy’s targeted customers want additional textures in their salad, particularly croutons and pieces of tortilla. Wendy’s has obliged them.
Finally, Munger recounted, Wendy’s learned that consumers want what she termed “flavor excitement.” She explained that Wendy’s tried to be a little adventurous with the new salad line by using ingredients like cayenne pepper and pecans kicked up with sea salt.
As I’ve noted in an earlier post, I’ve tried the new salads. They’re a true advance for fast food. Little did I know how much research had gone into the line.
Thursday, September 30, 2010
What they're saying about Eataly
A snippets of conversations overheard at lunchtime today in Eataly, the new Italian food complex opened in New York City by Mario Batali, Lidia Bastianich, Joe Bastianich and several other big-name kitchen stars:
Thirtysomething man in casual business attire, about to hurt his neck as his head snaps around to take it all in--the restaurants, the food stalls, the displays of cheese and salumi: This place is sick.
Thirtysomething female companion, apparently a co-worker, after nodding vigorishly: I could live here.
Thirtysomething man in casual business attire, about to hurt his neck as his head snaps around to take it all in--the restaurants, the food stalls, the displays of cheese and salumi: This place is sick.
Thirtysomething female companion, apparently a co-worker, after nodding vigorishly: I could live here.
Wednesday, September 29, 2010
Local movement hits a turnip in the road
Wanted: Enough locally grown hemp to weave a few nooses. Locavores are ready to string some beans after being conned by an opportunist or two with field mud on their boots.
It’s not uncommon for the growers who populate farmers markets to use natural fertilizers on their crops. A few, it seems, have been slinging BS of a different sort. Products they’ve been hawking as locally grown were actually harvested hundreds of miles away and warehoused, as several investigative reports have revealed.
The Pulitzer Prize-worthy piece was last week’s report by the NBC affiliate in Los Angeles. Reporters for the station bought produce at local farmers markets, then paid surprise visits to the farms where the items were purportedly being grown. Instead of planted fields, they found weed-covered lots.
Presented with the evidence, some of the lying growers ‘fessed up. Hence the hemp request. Locavores regard farmers markets as sacred grounds. These slicksters in overalls were desecrating the virtual birthplaces of the buy-local movement.
Refuting claims of a food being locally sourced has become downright popular in the United Kingdom. The London Mail focused on restaurants’ deceptions, noting that lambs supposedly from the countryside had actually been raised and butchered in New Zealand, on the other side of the globe. A locally made pie of locally grown apples actually came from a supermarket aisle, the story noted. And half the local cheeses it investigated were actually imported from other nations.
Don’t mash my turnips for saying this, but it’s not surprising that such a thing could happen. Sales of locally sourced foods are skyrocketing, in part because of the prices they can command.. The poor schlub who grows nothing but peanuts for a big multinational food processor doesn’t want to miss the opportunity.
Clearly safeguards will have to be implemented to verify the origins of what markets and restaurants sell as locally grown. That, unfortunately, flies in the face of the movement’s informality and almost bohemian sense.
But doing nothing will open the produce stalls to more charlatans, and that would certainly hamper the sea-salt change that’s taking place in America’s eating habits.
It’s not uncommon for the growers who populate farmers markets to use natural fertilizers on their crops. A few, it seems, have been slinging BS of a different sort. Products they’ve been hawking as locally grown were actually harvested hundreds of miles away and warehoused, as several investigative reports have revealed.
The Pulitzer Prize-worthy piece was last week’s report by the NBC affiliate in Los Angeles. Reporters for the station bought produce at local farmers markets, then paid surprise visits to the farms where the items were purportedly being grown. Instead of planted fields, they found weed-covered lots.
Presented with the evidence, some of the lying growers ‘fessed up. Hence the hemp request. Locavores regard farmers markets as sacred grounds. These slicksters in overalls were desecrating the virtual birthplaces of the buy-local movement.
Refuting claims of a food being locally sourced has become downright popular in the United Kingdom. The London Mail focused on restaurants’ deceptions, noting that lambs supposedly from the countryside had actually been raised and butchered in New Zealand, on the other side of the globe. A locally made pie of locally grown apples actually came from a supermarket aisle, the story noted. And half the local cheeses it investigated were actually imported from other nations.
Don’t mash my turnips for saying this, but it’s not surprising that such a thing could happen. Sales of locally sourced foods are skyrocketing, in part because of the prices they can command.. The poor schlub who grows nothing but peanuts for a big multinational food processor doesn’t want to miss the opportunity.
Clearly safeguards will have to be implemented to verify the origins of what markets and restaurants sell as locally grown. That, unfortunately, flies in the face of the movement’s informality and almost bohemian sense.
But doing nothing will open the produce stalls to more charlatans, and that would certainly hamper the sea-salt change that’s taking place in America’s eating habits.
Thursday, September 16, 2010
Better fare to be the bomb this fall
Who knew foodies were lurking beneath the beer-can hats and face paint? There’s no denying that today’s football fan, and the tailgating variety in particular, have been splicing some Rachel Ray episodes into the ESPN highlight reels.
Consider the findings of the Weber grill company’s annual survey of NFL ticket holders: Half of tailgaters, the fanatics who host a pre-game cookout outside the stadium, regard themselves as gourmets.
Half those parking-lot culinarians prefer to grill seafood instead of the usual burgers and brats. Perhaps not surprisingly, they tend to draw 20 fellow fans to sample their fare, compared with a mean of 14 for the pedestrian grillers.
Even more telling are stadium feeders’ announcements of the new restaurants they’re showcasing at pro arenas this season. The localization trend hasn’t taken a time-out during gridiron season. Contract management companies like Centerplate and Delaware North have added feeding stations that specialize in home-city favorites, from crab cakes at the Baltimore’s Raven’s home roost to a fried pork tenderloin sandwich at the Indianapolis Colts’ ballpark.
A competitor, Delaware North’s Sportservcie, said it searched for menu ideas in the New Jersey towns surrounding the concessionaire’s newest charge, the Meadowlands home of the Jets and the Giants. The rookie stadium is featuring such “Jersey Shore”-authentic fare as pepper and egg sandwiches and Nonna Fusco’s Meatballs, made from the recipe of Sportservice executive chef Eric Borgia.
Still, the management companies aren’t neglecting fans with more traditional stadium tastes. Centerplate-managed facilities will feature a 2 Point Conversion deal, or two hot dogs available at a combo price, and a refillable peanut cup for anyone who buys a drink to accompany the snack.
Sportservice said it will have 91 portable beer carts at the new Meadowland stadium.
Consider the findings of the Weber grill company’s annual survey of NFL ticket holders: Half of tailgaters, the fanatics who host a pre-game cookout outside the stadium, regard themselves as gourmets.
Half those parking-lot culinarians prefer to grill seafood instead of the usual burgers and brats. Perhaps not surprisingly, they tend to draw 20 fellow fans to sample their fare, compared with a mean of 14 for the pedestrian grillers.
Even more telling are stadium feeders’ announcements of the new restaurants they’re showcasing at pro arenas this season. The localization trend hasn’t taken a time-out during gridiron season. Contract management companies like Centerplate and Delaware North have added feeding stations that specialize in home-city favorites, from crab cakes at the Baltimore’s Raven’s home roost to a fried pork tenderloin sandwich at the Indianapolis Colts’ ballpark.
A competitor, Delaware North’s Sportservcie, said it searched for menu ideas in the New Jersey towns surrounding the concessionaire’s newest charge, the Meadowlands home of the Jets and the Giants. The rookie stadium is featuring such “Jersey Shore”-authentic fare as pepper and egg sandwiches and Nonna Fusco’s Meatballs, made from the recipe of Sportservice executive chef Eric Borgia.
Still, the management companies aren’t neglecting fans with more traditional stadium tastes. Centerplate-managed facilities will feature a 2 Point Conversion deal, or two hot dogs available at a combo price, and a refillable peanut cup for anyone who buys a drink to accompany the snack.
Sportservice said it will have 91 portable beer carts at the new Meadowland stadium.
Labels:
Centerplate,
Delaware North,
football,
sports concessions,
Sportservice
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)